This is an example of a Rubric we are still developing better Rubrics.
Present
|
1 novice
|
2 advanced
|
3 expert
|
4 “super” expert
|
Use of Voice
|
Talk to soft and monotonous
|
Loud enough but monotonous
|
Loud enough but monotonous
|
Loud enough good pitch difference
|
Attitude
|
Looks to his feet
|
Looks occasionally in the crowd
|
Looks in the crowd but has only occasional contact with his listeners
|
Looks good in the crowd and has good contact with his listeners
|
Interaction
|
Does his story and gives no possibility to ask questions
|
Does his story and gives possibility to ask questions at the end
|
Askes questions to his listeners during the talk
|
Askes questions to his listeners during the story, attracting responses from the crowd and reacts on them
|
Material
|
No additional material
|
Material hardly overlaps the talk
|
Material is consistent with material, but adds nothing
|
Material will add colour to the talk
|
Use of language
Type language
|
Street language
|
Civilized street language
|
Correct English with occasional street language
|
Correct English
|
Fluent speak
|
Does not consecutive sentences
|
Occasionally reluctance little consistency and many "euh"
|
Few doubts reasonable consistency and little "euh"
|
Good coherent sentences
|
Pronunciation
|
Hardly hearable
|
Fair to be heard but poorly articulated
|
Well understood but not well-articulated
|
Well understood and well-articulated
|
Organizing the message
|
No line in the story, ramble on
|
Barely line in the story but still ramble on
|
A line in the story but on still ramble on
|
A tight story
|
Introduction
|
No Introduction
|
There is an introduction but that does not make any sense
|
A minimum introduction but clear
|
A clear introduction
|
Closure
|
Sudden silence as closure
|
"This was the end" as completion
|
A minimum completion without summary
|
A clear conclusion with summary and acceptance speech
|